Dont Buy Stocks based on P/E Ratio alone

I use the P/E ratio as a secondary indicator for buying and selling stocks but I don't use the ratio in the same a manner as many value investors teach. I will explain the difference in my methodology for using the P/E ratio to your advantage.

Many value investors will pass on a growth stock that has a P/E ratio higher than a predetermined level. For example, they may discard all stocks that have a ratio of 15 or higher, no matter what industry group they come from. Some investors will discard any stocks that have P/E ratios above the industry group averages, concluding that they are grossly overvalued. I am not saying that this method doesn't work, because it does but it will not work when you focus on buying young innovative small cap stocks that are growing at tremendous rates, rates that "big caps" can no longer sustain.

I have never passed on buying a stock due to its P/E ratio being too high. What is too high? Too high to one investor may be low to another investor. This is the same logic that I use when speaking of stock's prices. One problem that have with some value investors is their lack of understanding of the movement of the P/E ratio line on a chart. As a stock begins to move 100% or 200% from its pivot point, the P/E ratio will also move higher over the course of time. Plotting the P/E ratio on a chart will show you how much of a gain the ratio has made as the stock continues its up-trend.

Value investors that pass on buying stocks with P/E ratio's above a certain threshold have missed some of the biggest winners of all time (the 10-baggers as Peter Lynch would say). Analysts frequently downgrade stocks when their P/E ratios cross what they believe to be fully valued thresholds.

Some things in life are worth more than other things although they offer the same use, such as a car. I tend to use this example often but I would rather own a Mercedes for $50k over a Pinto for $10k. They will both take me where I want to go but I value the amenities that the Mercedes gives me and the added comfort, quality and style that comes with the luxury vehicle. The same holds true for stocks, certain companies offer greater appeal and are valued at higher ratios than their competitors. The best materialistic things in life, including growth stocks, are usually bought at a premium.

The P-E ratio uses a stock's current price and divides it by total earnings per share over the past four quarters. For example, currently GDP has a P/E ratio 51.06 with a share price of $24.00. Its last four quarters of EPS add up to $0.47. Its P-E ratio is $24.00 divided by $0.47, or 51.06. MSN Money Central has the P/E ratio listed at 51.30.

Growth stocks usually sport higher P/E ratios than the rest of the general market, even at the start of up-trends. A high P/E ratio typically means that the stock is enjoying strong demand. If a stock climbs in price from 40 to 60, its P/E ratio also gains 50%. Even though the P/E ratio may be high according to some analysts and value investors, the stock may be about to breakout from a cup-with-handle and go on to double from this point. Would you want to miss out on a possible 100% gain because the P/E ratio is too high?

Investor's Business Daily conducted an excellent case study in 1996-97: "The 95 best small- and mid-cap stocks of 1996-97 had an average P-E of 39 at their pivot and 87 at the peak of their run-ups. The 25 best large caps of those years began with an average P-E of 20 and rose to 37. To get a piece of these big winners, you had to pay a premium."

When I purchase a stock, I note the current P/E ratio and chart it along with the price. Historically, P/E's that move up 100%-200% or more while the stock is advancing, usually become vulnerable stocks and can start to become extended and flash sell signals. It holds true for a stock with a P/E starting at 15 and going to 40 or a stock with a P/E of 50 and going to 115. Don't skip over EXCELLENT companies that are growing at amazing clips because of a high P/E ratio. What may seem high now, may be low later on! Earnings and Sales are much more important. Price and volume are the most important. The P/E ratio is just a secondary indicator that can be used to further analyze the stocks in your portfolio.

Always use price and volume as your first line of offense and defense. From this point, turn to some dependable secondary indicators to confirm your original analysis and then make a decision. I would never throw out a stock because its P/E ratio is too high. Take GOOG for example, every value investor missed the 100% gain that this stock boasted after the release of its IPO. Growth stocks are expensive for a reason, don't forget the analogy to a Mercedes.

Chris Perruna - http://www.marketstockwatch.com

Chris is the Founder and President of MarketStockWatch.com, an internet community that teaches you how to invest your money with solid rules. We don't stop at just showing you our daily and weekly screens, we teach you how to make your own screens through education. Through our philosophy, you will be able to create your own methods and styles to become successful.

New investor email lists and leads posted - including active real ... PR Web (press release), WA - Aug 20, 2008 ... finance executives, owners of tax free investments, Canadian investment responders, individuals interested in stocks, mutual funds, rare coins, ...

Investing early is best strategy Miramichi Leader, Canada - Aug 19, 2008 You can invest in equity in many ways: stocks, mutual funds, indexes or private companies. Yes, there are risks, but there is also the potential for greater ...

SEC Weighs Overhaul of 'Index' Annuities Wall Street Journal - Aug 16, 2008 But the SEC wants indexed annuities to be considered "securities," just like stocks, mutual funds and even variable annuities. ...

But spend wisely, says financial planner Belleville Intelligencer, Canada - Aug 19, 2008 "You are insulating yourself from the adversity of the economy if you invest in stocks, mutual funds and, of course, an emergency savings account. ...

Money Tip: ETFs stable in turbulent markets Baxter Bulletin, AR - Jul 25, 2008 Trading in exchange-traded funds has been stable and strong despite recent troubles in financial markets. Like mutual funds, ETFs are single investments ...

Ibbotson Selected by ING Financial Advisers to Create Model ... MarketWatch - Aug 13, 2008 Morningstar provides data on more than 280000 investment offerings, including stocks, mutual funds, and similar vehicles. The company has operations in 18 ...

Easy-to-Use Solution Allows Retirement Plans to Offer Allocation ... MarketWatch - Aug 6, 2008 Morningstar provides data on more than 270000 investment offerings, including stocks, mutual funds, and similar vehicles. The company has operations in 18 ...

Banking crisis a surprise most saw coming The Age, Australia - Aug 5, 2008 And, as the FDIC site explains, it does not insure investments held in banks such as bonds, stocks, mutual funds, life insurance policies, or municipal ...

Morningstar Announces Two New Fund Categories, One Broad Asset Class MarketWatch - Aug 5, 2008 Morningstar provides data on more than 280000 investment offerings, including stocks, mutual funds, and similar vehicles. The company has operations in 18 ...

Los Angeles Times

Should you buy a home now? Los Angeles Times, CA - Aug 3, 2008 But renters can take the money they would have spent on a down payment and invest it in stocks, mutual funds or other investments (20% down on the ...